January 2023

Equality Movement – January 2023 Review

The Equality Movement is an organization supporting LGBTQI people, whose goal is to promote the full integration of the LGBTQI community and women in society. The Equality Movement fights to eliminate homophobia and sexism in society. Accordingly, the organization provides need-based social and legal service delivery and community mobilization, as well as works to change public awareness and policy advocacy.

We present to you the activities of the Equality Movement in the month of January 2023:

  • In the month of January 2023, the Equality Movement provided social, legal and mental health services to 96 representatives of the LGBTQ+ community.
  • Within the framework of the health and AIDS prevention program, the organization provided preventive means to 332 people during the month of January, and 298 beneficiaries were tested for sexually transmitted infections (STIs). In addition, 231 people subscribed to a preventive kit and an AIDS self-test through selftest.ge in different cities of Georgia. In addition, 38 new beneficiaries joined the PrEP program and 16 people received the chemical sex package.
  • Together with the “Eurasian Men’s Health Coalition” and the Association Temida, the Equality Movement submitted a report to the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) on “Violations of Human Rights Based on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Georgia”. The report assesses incidents of hate crimes and violence against LGBT+ people. The document discusses gender based, as well as domestic and sexual violence against LBT women. In addition, the report includes a document related to the legal recognition of gender, the exercise of the right to health care, employment and housing.
  • On January 13, 2022, the organization discussed the legal situation of LGBTQI people in Georgia and the challenges facing the community in a meeting with Fara Karim, deputy chairman of the Committee on Democracy, Human Rights and Humanitarian Issues of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly, who is visiting Georgia at the invitation of the Swedish Embassy, and the speaker of the same committee, Johan Bueser.
  • In January 2023, the Equality Movement, with the support of the National Democracy Institute (NDI), completed work on a video campaign. The concept and main messages of the campaign are based on the document “Study of Social and Economic Needs of the LGBTQI Community in Georgia”. As part of the campaign, three videos were prepared for distribution on social media (duration — 90 seconds) and one video clip of the type of social advertisement (duration — 30 seconds). The video campaign focuses on the links between poverty and homophobia. The videos depict the barriers that LGBTQ people in Georgia face in terms of access to decent working conditions, quality education and healthcare services, as well as housing.

See also:

  • Temida — January 2023 review
  • Tbilisi Pride — Review of January 2023
  • Women’s Foundation in Georgia – January 2023 review

 

Organizers of July 5th are demanding restrictions on LGBTQI people’s demonstrations — draft law

The members of the homophobic and violent party, the conservative movement, who are also the organizers of the July 5 violence, are demanding changes to the law of Georgia “on gatherings and demonstrations”. Giorgi Kardava, Zurab Makharadze, Irakli Morgoshia, Shota Martynenko and Konstantine Morgoshia want to ban such gatherings and manifestations, which aim or during which there may be “demonstrating, popularizing and/or propaganda of sexual orientation”.

In addition, the law drafted by the violent group states that it should be prohibited to hold an assembly or demonstration “if it aims at or during which there may be any statements or calls that are against any religious movement, defamatory and/or against the beliefs of people of any religious sect, insulting or / and during which there may be war and propaganda of violence, incitement of national, regional, religious or social strife”.

In addition to the Law on Assemblies and Manifestations, the project envisages changes in administrative offenses and criminal codes. Leaders of violent and homophobic groups demand a change in the Code of Administrative Offenses, according to which violation of the norms provided for in Articles 9, 10¹, 11 and 11¹ of the Law of Georgia on Assembly and Manifestation will lead to a fine in the amount of 3,000 GEL or administrative imprisonment for up to 25 days. And if the violator is an organizer – fined in the amount of 5,000 GEL or administrative imprisonment for up to 30 days.

As for the Criminal Code, the leaders of the violent groups demand that Article 347 of the following content of the repeated violation of the rule of assembly or demonstration be added to the Code:

“Repeated violation of the norms provided for in Articles 9, 10¹, 11 and 11¹ of the Law of Georgia on Assembly and Manifestations — is punishable by a fine or community service for a term of 180 to 240 hours or corrective work for a term of up to 2 years with imprisonment for a term of 2 with deprivation of the right to hold office or work for a period of up to 3 years”.

According to the explanation of the bill, the leaders of violent and homophobic groups in the card indicate that the request for the mentioned changes is related to the events of 2013-2021, when “attempts to hold events related to the public demonstration of sexual orientation in public space caused public excitement and mass protests of the population, which clearly showed that in Georgian society, conducting similar events in the space of these cultural and ethnic values represents the crossing of the threshold that the state and society set regarding the norms of behavior in the public space.

According to them, “seeing similar activities in public space, especially by children, is strongly unacceptable for the population, therefore, it is necessary to clearly formulate the rules for holding public gatherings and demonstrations, because in the interests of public peace and security, similar events should be avoided.”

Violent groups name the “deficiency” of the current legal regulations as the basis for initiating the draft law and claim that “the legal regulations are not exhaustive, leaving an opportunity for individuals and groups of individuals to abuse the legal regulation and achieve an illegal goal with their own interpretation.”

The bill has already been submitted to the Bureau of the Parliament. In the decision of the Bureau dated December 12, 2022, it is written that “on the basis of the proposal of the Legal Affairs Committee of the Parliament of Georgia, presented by at least 25,000 voters in the manner of a legislative initiative”, consideration of the draft law should begin in committees and factions. The period from February 8 to May 5, 2023 is indicated as the estimated date of consideration of the bill at the plenary session.

According to the current legislation in Georgia, a permit is not required to hold the rally. In the event that the assembly or demonstration is held in a place of traffic or obstructs traffic, the organizers must notify the executive body of the municipality in advance, unless traffic is blocked for reasons independent of the assembly or demonstration. The municipality must discuss the feasibility of changing the place and time of the gathering or demonstration with the organizers within 3 days and give them a written recommendation if:

  • assembly or demonstration poses a real threat to the normal functioning of enterprises, institutions and organizations;
  • Another action (about which a warning was filed earlier with the executive body of the municipality) is planned to be held at the same place and at the same time.

The authors of the draft law demand that all the changes that will be included in the existing law take effect on the 15th day after the publication of the law.

Note: Constantly attempts by violent and homophobic groups to associate the freedom of expression of LGBTQ people with “propaganda” or “promotion” are wrong. Apart from the fact that “propaganda” of sexual orientation or gender identity is impossible, according to Georgian legislation, every person has freedom of expression.

TEMIDA — January 2023 review

Temida is a queer-activist, trans* community organization that organizes, works and fights to build a safe, equal and dignified political, legal and social environment for trans* and queer people. The goal of the organization is to build a dignified, equal and fair political, legal and social environment for trans people, where their needs, concerns, challenges and rights are recognized and supported by the state and society.

We present to you the activities of TEMIDA in the month of January 2023:

 

TEMIDA presented the annual report

TEMIDA resumed work on January 9. One of the first activities of the new working year was an employment workshop held on January 21, which was held online so that members of the queer and trans* community who could not attend the physical workshops could attend.

The purpose of employment workshops is to provide jobseekers with information on employment opportunities, their labor rights, and to help improve skills and competencies that will significantly increase their employability.

The employment workshops were aimed at trans* and non-binary gender identity people, the January 21 workshop was the final meeting for this phase, however the organization continues to work on the challenges and solutions to the employment of the trans* community.

The activity is carried out with the support of the organization “Women’s Fund Georgia”.

Media campaign 

In December, TEMIDA launched a social media campaign addressing the situation and challenges of the trans* and queer community in the field of employment. The purpose of the campaign is to promote the needs of the community and promote the actualization and implementation of anti-discrimination and community-oriented policies in the workplace.

In January, two videos prepared as part of the “Dignified employment is our right” campaign were posted on Temida’s page on social networks. In one of the videos, Challenges of the LGBTQ Community in the Labor Market: Existing Experiences, social worker and employment consultant, Magda Modebadze, based on her own work experience, talks about the situation that exists in the trans* and queer community and is related to the existing problems and barriers in terms of employment, which the community members are often excluded from the labor market and have limited access to decent employment opportunities.

In the third video prepared as part of the campaign, which was posted on the organization’s social pages in January, activist Nata Talikishvili talks about her own experience, which puts an important emphasis and shows us how vulnerable institutionalized homo/bi and transphobia makes community members both in the labor market and in other areas.

In the framework of the mentioned campaign, informational posters will be prepared and placed on Temida’s Facebook and Instagram pages about the challenges of the LGBTQ+ community in the labor market and the elimination of discriminatory practices.

The activity is carried out with the support of the organization “Women’s Fund Georgia”. Opinions expressed within the campaign may not reflect the views of the Foundation.

Alternative Report: Report on Violations of Human Rights Based on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Georgia

In January, Temida, together with ECOM (Eurasia Coalition for Health, Rights, Gender and Sexuality Diversity) and the Equality Movement, prepared an alternative report for the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) on “Violations of human rights based on sexual orientation and gender identity in Georgia”. 

The report critically assesses the current situation for trans* and queer people. It talks about the consequences of social and cultural exclusion, violations and issues in the direction of housing, employment, protection from violence, freedom of expression.

Women’s Fund in Georgia – January 2023 review

The Women’s Fund Georgia has existed in Georgia since 2005 and its mission is to strengthen women’s organizations and groups in the center and regions for the realization of women’s rights, their full participation in public life and self-realization.

We present to you the activities of the Foundation’s Women’s Fund in the month of January 2023:

  • In January, the foundation announced a new grant program called “Women’s Rights and Environmental Justice,” which aims to encourage women’s NGOs and informal women’s groups working on social and environmental justice to focus their efforts on women’s stewardship of natural resources, responding to social and environmental challenges, whether climate change, biodiversity, environmental pollution, chemical safety, waste management, women’s right to a safe, clean and healthy environment and others.
  • Also, the organization’s open door grant program has been launched, which is valid throughout the year.
  • The Women’s Fund has started preparing videos to raise awareness about digital security, which will be mainly aimed at the foundation’s grantees/activists.
  • On January 27, the Foundation organized a webinar on the anti-gender rhetoric of far-right groups.
  • On January 30, the Women’s Foundation held a conference on gender equality in labor relations, at which the organization summarized the achievements and challenges of 2022.

Tbilisi Pride — Review of January 2023

Tbilisi Pride is a civil association of LGBTQI people and supporters. The organization annually holds Pride Week in Tbilisi, puts LGBTQI issues on the political agenda, conducts surveys, and fights for the civil, political, and socio-economic rights of queer people in Georgia.

We present to you the activities of Tbilisi Pride in the month of January 2023:

  • The organization saw off the year 2022 with a grand night of drag ball, which was hosted by the club “KHIDI”. THE DRAG BALL: ALL STARS became one of the most memorable nights — new numbers by familiar and beloved artists, great music, New Year’s mood and a special guest, Georgian jazz legend Giuli Chokheli, will be remembered by the audience for a long time. Radio Liberty also dedicated a short documentary film to the ball.
  • In 2023, community meetings traditionally continue at the office of Tbilisi Pride. The organization started the year 2023 with the screening of Ioseb (Soso) Bliadze’s award-winning film “My Room”. The crowded meeting ended with a conversation with the director of the film and a discussion about the film.
  • On January 27, Tbilisi Pride hosted another community meeting, at which the organization’s office became a safe space for games, fun, and getting to know community members and like-minded people.
  • In January 2023, the organization launched a new multimedia project “Common Language”. “Common Language” is a particularly important project for Tbilisi Pride – a space in which the organization will try to find a common language through dialogue of interesting respondents on the most important and controversial topics for the society. On the Facebook page of the project, you can see the first program in which women and men talk about feminism.

Tbilisi Pride is planning many interesting activities in February. In addition, the organization’s birthday is approaching.

What kind of kindergarten is actually opening in Berlin

In one of Berlin’s areas, in Schöneberg, the so-called The rainbow garden will open. It is planned that the majority of the day center staff will be LGBTQ people.

The children’s daycare center, which will open in the spring of 2023, will increase queer visibility and representation. The said day center is part of a pilot project initiated by the Gay Counseling Service of Berlin.

The director of the day center, Marcel de Groot, explains the pedagogical approach in the pilot gardens. The concept is the same as other, typical daycare centers, with one difference — in experimental kindergartens, it will be clear to the children from the beginning that in addition to heterosexual couples, there are also queer couples, and this is a part of life. According to de Groot, queer visibility for children will be available through books in which not only a prince and a princess, but a prince and a prince fall in love. By convention, 3 out of 10 books will have queer characters. According to the concept, if the children are not heterosexual, this knowledge will make it easier for them to accept themselves.

“Parents hope that they will find more acceptance with us than at other day care centers,” says Grout.

The kindergarten is intended for 93 children. According to todaytimeslive.com, as of October 1, 2022, the number of those wishing to enroll in the kindergarten was 60.

In an article published in berliner-zeitung.de, one of the children’s parents said that she and her partner, who have children together, would welcome the opening of such a daycare center.

“Rainbow families in our circle of acquaintances have wanted a similar center for a long time. This is because many of them have experienced discrimination in day care centers.”

The mother, who chose to remain anonymous, says she has to walk a long distance every day to take her son to the said day care center. She said she would rather travel half an hour more but have her son in a center that is more accepting and representative of queer people.

In this day center, in which, like other kindergartens, it is explained to the children that in addition to heterosexual couples, there are also queer couples. In addition, they share the information they need about sexuality education, which involves covering age-appropriate topics, for example: knowing your own body, recognizing signs of abuse and reporting it to adults, saying “no” when you feel uncomfortable, setting/protecting boundaries, and similar issues.

Information was spread about the connection with the kindergarten of sociologist Rudiger Lautman, who in 1994 published the book “Longing for children. A portrait of a pedophile”. According to him, he wanted to scientifically explain the behavior of criminals, but because part of the public understood it as a call for the legalization of pedophilia, he withdrew the book from sales. In addition, according to the managing director Marcel de Groot, Lautman has no connection with the day care center.

Queer contacted Marika Artmeladze, a pre-school education specialist living in Berlin, who works as a teacher in one of Berlin’s kindergartens.

According to Marika, the spread information, as if the said day center will help to “change” the sexuality of children, is incorrect.

“It will promote acceptance,” says Marika.

According to her, in general, one of the tasks of German kindergartens is to prepare children for living in a diverse society and not to single out people from different grounds.

“Our society is diverse, it consists of individuals and each of them is important. One of the tasks of the kindergarten education system is to prepare children for life in a diverse society, and the kindergarten is one of the first places where conscious education and parenting concepts are introduced, through which the introduction of diversity of consciousness should be created. The fact that diversity can have any effect on a child’s sexual development is an absolute absurdity, and those people who tax it, have no possibility of any scientific substantiation,” says Marika.

She emphasizes that it is very important for the child to get used to the diversity of people from the kindergarten age. According to Marika, it is her duty as an educator to support all children in their individuality.

“There are children who come from the ‘Regenbogenfamilie’, aka the ‘Rainbow Family’; There are children with queer parents; There are children whose parents are separated; There are children whose family involves relationships between men and women. This variety exists in Germany, and kindergarten is one of the first places where a child gains experience.”

According to Marika, German kindergartens are guided by the concept of the World Health Organization, which was developed in 2011 in relation to children’s sexual education. In the Berlin Education Regulations, which governs the Berlin Kindergartens, one of the clauses is health, and sex education and the promotion of sex education is a subsection of health.

“This means knowing about your own body, keeping boundaries, saying ‘no’, asking for help, etc. This is a very broad spectrum and it would be very wrong to reduce it and compare it with the sexuality of adults and say that children are being “perverted”, – says Marika.

 

The Court of Appeals acquitted those convicted of group violence in the July 5 case and reduced their sentences

The Court of Appeal reduced the sentences of those convicted in the July 5, 2021 group violence case. The decision was announced today, January 16, by judge Maia Tetrauli.

6 persons convicted in the case of July 5 – Davit Kutaladze, Akaki Nakashidze, Tornike Davlasheridze, Tsotne Chikhladze, Gia Giguashvili and Otar Gelashvili – were acquitted by the decision of the second instance under the second part of Article 225 of the Criminal Code, which involves participation in group violence. With this decision, the 5-year prison sentence given by the first instance was reduced to 4 years.

According to Interpressnews, the announcement of the decision in the Court of Appeal was followed by noise. Family members and relatives of the detainees insulted the plaintiffs and journalists and tried to damage the journalists’ video cameras. The bailiff defused the situation.

On July 5, 2021, on Rustaveli Avenue, where the march of dignity was planned, homophobic violent groups raided the offices of queer activists and physically assaulted journalists, including TV Pirveli operator Lexo Lashkarava, who received severe physical injuries and later died. According to the decision of the City Court of April 4, 2022, 6 persons arrested in connection with the case of July 5 were sentenced to 5 years in prison.

The convicts were charged with the third part of Article 118 and Articles 154 and 156 of the Criminal Code of Georgia, which involve less severe damage to health, obstruction of journalistic activity and persecution.

The road from Jordan to Georgia – the story of Shafik Salim Shafik Hamarne

“From an early age, I was attracted to boys, and I was particularly close to my mother and sister. At that time, with stereotypical things, for example, playing with dolls, you could understand that I did not have the same interests as other boys, but realizing this and coming out happened much later, at the age of 14-15,” recalls Shafiq Salim Shafiq Hamarneh, a gay boy from Jordan who escaped from the oppressive environment of his native country in Georgia, a country that he loved from afar, but upon his arrival he realized that behind the beautiful nature there were also homophobic and xenophobic attitudes of the society. On his Tiktok page, he shares his experience of living in Georgia, daily self-reported news, including the sad facts that sometimes make him think – “maybe coming to live in Georgia was a mistake”.

In Jordan, homosexuality has been decriminalized since the 50s of the last century, although there is no anti-discrimination law in the country, moreover, any form of relationship between same-sex couples that takes place in public space can be a prerequisite for imprisonment for “offending public morals”. The criminalization of killing a family member “in the name of dignity” happened only recently, in 2013. At the same time, public attitudes are strongly negative — according to a 2019 survey, more than 90% of Jordanian citizens consider homosexuality unacceptable.

When speaking to Queer, Shafik talked about coming out to himself, his time in Jordan and the oppression he experienced in Georgia.

Self-discovery and support

“At first I was in denial, trying to see girls in a romantic way, but to no avail. It was almost like an obsession to somehow push my attraction to boys out of my head. Because of that, I had depression, I had to go through medical treatment and slowly I was able to accept the facts,” he says while talking about the subsequent difficulty of understanding his sexual orientation and tells us that some of his family members, his mother and sister, know that he is gay and today they are already supportive, although in the beginning It wasn’t like that — “At first, my mother also had a hard time accepting this fact, she told me that I was just having such a period. My aunt, who does not live in Jordan, explained that there was nothing special about it and gradually became much more accepting. Then I had a romantic relationship, we were together for 3 years. He often stayed with us and my mother and my sister knew that we were in love. My father, who I remember from a young age abusing  my mother, does not know. Fortunately, they are now divorced. If my father found out about my orientation while I was living in Jordan, I don’t know what would have happened. I have no guarantee that he would not kill me.”

Public pressure

He says that in Jordan it is especially difficult to withstand the pressure from the society – queer people and their family members are constantly called that they are sinners, that it is degrading to have a queer person in the family.

“That’s why family members are sometimes less accepting, the sexual orientation of a family member is damaging to the reputation of other family members. They consider you a sinner, they don’t talk to your family anymore, they completely cut you off. Publicly announcing your orientation, expressing yourself is dangerous, you can be killed, your family will throw you out of the house, and even in the case of murder, the punishment is very small. Therefore, queer people are actively leaving the country,” he says.

Shafiq recalls one incident that happened while living in Jordan, when he was walking hand in hand with his partner and, as he says, smoked a small amount of marijuana. He was stopped by the police and arrested for drug addiction, although he said the real reason was seeing signs of romance between queer people in public.

“Thus, people are often arrested for “offending public dignity”. I remember another case when about 10 gay men had a party at home and all of them were arrested, but they were not even in a public space,” Shafiq recalls .

Life in Georgia

“I don’t know if coming here was a good decision or not. There are moments when I regret it,” says Shafiq, speaking about his decision to come to Georgia.

Sharif recalls many incidents in the past year, when he faced mockery and attacks from citizens and the police.

“I was assaulted near Freedom Square, I had blond hair at that time. I asked one of the people for directions and he attacked me for no reason at all. I went to the police, I had the footage, I waited for a few hours for the translator, who eventually came, but they didn’t really know English, it was a terrible inconvenience, and I immediately said that I didn’t want to file a complaint anymore,” Shafiq recalls.

He recounts another incident where drunken men forcibly removed his scarf and verbally assaulted him, and recalls an incident when he was mobbed by people.

“Another case that I remember happened when I had left something in one of the service facilities, by the timeI turned around, it had already closed, and I asked the people gathered there what I could do. They started pointing the middle finger and making derogatory comments. I had footage of the incident on my phone, which I showed  tothe police, they took me to the department, they wrote dowm my complaint, but no one contacted me anymore, moreover, there was a sarcastic attitude on the part of the police. Therefore, I don’t want to have contact with them anymore, I have no hope that they will protect my rights,” says Shafiq, and tells us that apart from such cases, there are often times when he has to listen to racist comments and threats.

At the end of the conversation, Shafiq tells us that he is in a hopeless situation and often doesn’t even believe that anything will change for the better.

“When my mother was in Georgia, her support helped me, but she returned to Jordan and I was left alone. I am actually in a hopeless situation, I am waiting for the right to live here and there is no answer, and now I am a citizen of another country and I have no leverage, and the organizations cannot help me much. I can’t go back to my country either, I’m afraid to go there. And here I don’t actually leave the house anymore, the depression is back. I don’t even have the motivation to interact with different organizations, I have run out of hope that something will change for the better,” says Shafiq.